All Members Community

 View Only
  • 1.  Use of Core Equipment by College Classes

    Posted 16 days ago
    I am curious to know if there are any cores with policies regarding use of core facilities by instructors for their college classes.  Let me give a couple of examples.  I have one instructor, who is affiliated with core facilities, who teaches an annual short course on microscope techniques.  On the last day of the class, he brings the students through the core for a 1-hour tour.  I am happy to oblige, because it's a simple tour, and I don't feel it's necessary to charge a fee.  However, I have another instructor who wishes to use the core microscope facility to collect data for an undergraduate biology course.  For the last two years, this instructor was allowed free time in the core, and both times, it required more than 10 hours of instrument time.  The instructor is a trained user and did the imaging, while the students watched.  This course has a lab fee associated with it.  With these facts in mind, I feel the need to put a policy in writing, regarding how much usage is acceptable for classes, and/or what kind of fees to charge for a course to use the imaging facility.  Although I support the idea of the core being used for a course, I believe I need sufficient advanced notice from the instructor, and I also believe that lab courses should be required to pay a fee to use the core.  I am really curious to hear if anyone out there has a policy or what kind of agreement do you have with instructors who use your facility for a class.

    Thanks!
    Anthony Stender
    Creighton University


  • 2.  RE: Use of Core Equipment by College Classes

    Posted 15 days ago

    Hi Anthony,

    We don't have any policy about students using the facility for regular teaching activity. However, as you mentioned, occasionally few instructors request a tour and/or use of the instrument ahead of time and we accommodate them. The key is advance notice so that you can plan your work around the teaching, especially if they are not paying a fee.

    First option is to bring this issue up with your immediate faculty advisor or supervisor and see how to handle this recurring event and put a policy together. It looks like this particular instructor is allowed to use the facility for the last two years for free which implies that your faculty advisor is aware of it and hasn't addressed it.

    The second, albeit slightly creative, option is to use this "free" session count toward your own teaching credit and a promotional opportunity for your core. After all, trained students will become your future customers!

    Hope this helps.



    ------------------------------
    Thayumanasamy Somasundaram
    Senior Research Associate
    Florida State University
    Tallahassee FL
    ------------------------------



  • 3.  RE: Use of Core Equipment by College Classes

    Posted 15 days ago

    Hi Anthony,

    We support a lot of classes in my Core at CSU, both at the undergraduate and graduate level. Some are just tours, others involve instrument demonstrations or actual class projects where students run samples and have to collect data themselves, and sometimes we give guest lectures. We usually send out an online Form several weeks before the start of the academic semester to all faculty to inquire about their plans to use the Core for their classes, which instruments, how much time, the type of support they need from the staff, etc. We then have a discussion in person to plan and set boundaries. I find this approach more effective than a formal policy as every class is different, but I can see value in a general policy as a starting point (do share if you develop one!). We always charge for the instrument time per our cost-recovery rules, but instead of charging this through the class lab fees and putting that cost on the students, most departments here at CSU have a dedicated fund/budget to support these educational activities. I usually send an estimate of upcoming costs to the department heads so they have an idea what to budget for. These are usually small costs for them and no more than a few $k. 

    Happy to talk more offline if you have more questions.

    Karolien



    ------------------------------
    Karolien Denef
    Director, Analytical Resources Core
    Colorado State University
    Fort Collins CO
    ------------------------------



  • 4.  RE: Use of Core Equipment by College Classes

    Posted 15 days ago

    Hi Karolien and all,

     

    I like the idea of charging the department if possible. Getting funds from class fees can be challenging.

     

    I am going to try your approach here as we want the Cores to be more integrated within classes when appropriate. I'll let you know how it goes.

     

    Best,

     

    Joe

     

    ----

    Joe Dragavon
     
    Director
    BioFrontiers Advanced Light Microscopy Core 
    JSCBB C315
    University of Colorado Boulder
     

    Arrange a Training or a Meeting: 43ec276be94b4ad5bdb7519f84eda1dc@colorado.edu?anonymous&ep=plink"> Click Here

    Website: https://advancedimaging.colorado.edu/
     
    Teams/Office: 303.735.6988
    Cell: 720.934.2933

     

     






  • 5.  RE: Use of Core Equipment by College Classes

    Posted 14 days ago
    Thanks everyone who replied.  It's good to hear what your thoughts are, and I would be glad to hear more input.  I didn't mean to imply that I would charge a course or students a lab fee.  I would actually bill the department, but I was trying to decide whether I should only charge "lab courses" or "all courses".  Since lab courses have associated lab fees, I feel more comfortable charging a department for that type of course.  But I think it also depends on the level of commitment and amount of time involved.  I also think it's critical that instructors speak to me before the start of a new semester, so we can schedule the activity with minimal disruption to other users.

    Anthony Stender
    Creighton University





  • 6.  RE: Use of Core Equipment by College Classes

    Posted 14 days ago

    I think the expectations of the core should be laid out to all users and departments. If faculty would like us to be involved in training (lecture or tours or hands on) for their classes, they should be discussing this with you first. We have gladly done all three methods. If the training is hands on or requires considerable core staff time/reagents then there must be a method for cost recovery. Charging the department seems like the path of least resistance especially if the students are not linked to any one PI. The agreement is a win-win for both parties since it leverages the core staff's expertise in enhancing the class curriculum while also enabling cores to list it as a training effort on their reports.

     

    Sridar

     






  • 7.  RE: Use of Core Equipment by College Classes

    Posted 15 days ago

    We put together an "education" rate for two of our cores that were frequently used for classes, because the classes consumed quite a bit of instrument time over the course of a semester. It was low (heavily subsidized), and done in consultation with the departments, who were covering the fees. 



    ------------------------------
    Natasha Nikolaidis
    Associate Director of Operations
    Purdue University
    West Lafayette IN
    ------------------------------



  • 8.  RE: Use of Core Equipment by College Classes

    Posted 14 days ago
    We have a course that teaches students how to isolate DNA and run PCR reactions.  They send the PCR products to me for Sanger sequencing, and I bill them the same rates I would any other customer.

    Probably not exactly the same situation, but maybe it is helpful.

    Roxann

    Roxann Ashworth, MHS
    Laboratory Director, Customer Liaison
    Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine
    Genetic Resources Core Facility (GRCF)
    Blalock 1004/1005
    600 N. Wolfe St. , Baltimore, MD 21287
    P 410-614-0702 | C 410-733-9994

    For publications containing data generated by our facility, please include the core name and core ID in the methods and/or acknowledgement sections: Genetic Resources Core Facility, RRID:SCR_018669